Article archive / December 1, 2014
Originally published: . Volume 5, No. 16. Source pages: 1, 3, 4.
At a November 21 planning meeting of the Louisiana Board of Examiners of Psychologists, board members described their intention to add to the list of reasons they can discipline psychologists.
In a handout to those attending the meeting, board members suggested wording for a new category of discipline: “Inappropriate behavior. Psychologists shall not behave in such a manner that would be regarded by other psychologists, Board members or Board staff, as unprofessional conduct, disparaging, disrespectful or as a discredit to the profession while practicing the profession of psych- ology or representing themselves as a psychologist.”
The move would be an addition to R.S. 37:2359, section “B” which currently includes 15 disciplinary categories, for the “denial,
revocation, or suspension of license.”
“One of the reasons we’re adding, proposing adding #16,” Chair Dr. Rita Culross told the group, “is because the APA [American Psychological Association] ethics code does not cover psychologist–psychologist interactions. It covers how you relate to clients but it doesn’t cover an interaction between two psychologists and that’s come up as an issue and we want to make it specific that you can’t engage in an unprofes- sional manner towards your colleagues, …” said Culross.
If the board decides to go forward they will introduce a bill at the 2015 legis- lature for change, and follow with writing Rules.
Among the materials provided by the board was
a copy of an anonymous letter (see below), sent to the board, following a November 10 email from Executive Director Kelly Parker. In that email, Parker noted the discussion may include, “profane communication in a professional setting directed at a client, another health care professional, a member of the public, or any profane communication directed at the Board, Board members, or its staff.”
Board members and attendees discussed the proposal for about 45 minutes at the November meeting, including the issue of free speech.
“This is actually not talking about speech, it’s talking about behavior,” Parker said. “It’s not talking about attempting to regulate the speech, it talking about someone’s behavior.”
Board member Dr. Joe Comaty said, “Clearly, the First Amendment does not absolutely protect free speech. There are limits on the rights of free speech, in a number of categories. One of which has to do with what’s considered in the context of federal regulations, ‘fighting words.’ And that’s where an individual uses language to incite another individual and its based on whether the other individual feels threatened.”
The board members indicated that Ms. Parker felt threatened by a licensee on the phone and this was an example of the type of problem the new law would cover.
“So for example,” said Comaty, “if someone calls the staff and threatens them, that could be considered a limit on the right of free speech and an
encroachment on the safety of that individual within the office. I don’t believe that the board or a member of the board’s staff should be subjected to threats from licensees, either implied or direct.”
“I believe that the board has a responsibility to take steps necessary to protect the safety of the staff,” he said. “The issue is whether the board has the authority to regulate the behavior of its licensees, and like I said,
that’s been upheld. And, I believe that it is appropriate for licensees to behave in an professional manner, and what we have not defined yet is what the limits of that are.”
“We have people who will curse on the phone to our staff,” said Dr. Darla Burnett. “That’s inappropriate behavior.”
Parker told the group that Canada has a code of professionalism, and that Oregon is implementing one. Also, she said, Nevada is looking into the topic. “And I can’t tell you what we deal with at the board office,” she said.
“This is a growing thing,” Vice Chair, Dr. Marc Zimmermann, said. “Professionalism is a growing thing separated out from ethics.” He explained that the lawyers have policies for professionalism.
Attendees and board members also discussed whether current law and Rules should be satisfactory in covering behaviors that would be of concern.
Currently the law includes 15 items as grounds for discipline, in R.S. 37:2359. These include endangering the welfare of patients, harassment, sexual conduct, gross malpractice or gross negligence. Also included are certain types of fraud, deception, lying, and exploitation. Also, #12 includes ethics violations and “other immoral, unprofes- sional, or dishonorable
conduct as defined in the rules and regulations of the board.”
Dr. Joe Tramontana, current president of the Louisiana Psychological Association, said, “I could be wrong, but I seem to remember that APA used to have something in the code about character assassination of our colleagues. It might not be there anymore. Am I wrong?”
Dr. Comaty responded, “The problem is that it is in the preamble to the code, which is aspirational and not enforceable. But yes, it does speak to the issue of professional behavior. As do other references. ASBBP is working on a code of conduct.”
“We have looked at this from a federal level, from a constitutional level, from a regulatory level,” said Comaty, “and there’s a concept in constitutional law called the govern- ment’s authority to regulate the Bar. And that speaks specifically to the regulatory authority of, in this case the Bar Association, to regulate the behavior of its individuals who are licensed under the Bar,” he said.
“This, in the broad context, actually extends this authority to all regulatory boards to regulate the behavior of
its licensees, so that the safety of the public is protected. Part of the safety of the public is appropriate professional behavior. So, this clearly is within the scope of the authority of regulatory agencies,” Comaty said.
Dr. Darla Burnett said, “Rule number 12 actually says, ‘other moral, unprofessional, or dishonorable conduct. We don’t have Rules that cover the things such as Joe’s mentioning,” she said.
“For me,” said Dr. Phil Griffin, “there’s no teeth in it. It doesn’t really say anything. It just saying behave like a lady or a gentleman.”
“And the fact that it is happening on a more regular basis, raises the level of concern,” said Dr. Comaty, “to the point where its necessary to consider something that would address issues in a specific manner, by the APA code of ethics. That’s why, the frequency with which this occurs across the country, in other jurisdictions, that ASPPB is drafting a code of conduct.”
“Psychologists calling other psychologists names, as is mentioned, in public. Where it might influence the concern of a client, a patient, the public. The profession has to be respected, and when we have licensees who behave in a manner that does discredit to the profession vis a vis the public. I believe that is the appropriate purview for the regulatory board,” he said.
Discussion included whether it is the board’s responsibility to protect a profession.
“When it has an effect on the clients,” said Dr. Culross, “it certainly does because the board is representing to the public that these are the individuals who are duly licensed and okay to treat you, and if you have the behavior where one psychologist is disparaging another, for no reason at all, then that public is denied access to that second individual,” she said.
“… we just wanted to review the list,” said Parker, current Executive Director, “since we’ve been having so many issues. We’ve actually been very busy in the investigation arena.”
Dr. Culross said the board has not voted on the matter, and “We will take all these comments under consideration and continue to explore this issue.”
Dr. Rita Culross, current Chair of the psychology board, and Dr. Marc Zimmermann, Vice Chair, listen to attendees at the November 21 Long-Range Planning meeting of the LSBEP.
Dr. Joe Tramontana looks on as Dr. Darlyne Nemeth suggests a change in wording about internship experiences for those using the title neuropsychologist.
This article is part of a historical newspaper archive. Read the original issue for its original layout, photographs and graphics.