Permanent Present Tense: The Unforgettable Life of the Amnesic Patient, H.M.

Article archive / December 1, 2014

Originally published: . Volume 5, No. 16. Source pages: 12.

Permanent Present Tense: The Unforgettable Life of the Amnesic Patient, H.M. is a scientific biography of Henry Molaison, perhaps the most intensively studied patient in the history of neurology, written by Suzanne Corkin, a psychologist who did research with him for forty-six years. In 1953 Molaison underwent brain surgery in an attempt to treat his intractable seizure disorder. The neurosurgeon removed the hippocampi and surrounding tissues from both hemispheres of his brain, despite a lack of clear-cut evidence regarding the point of origin of his seizures. From a present perspective the surgeon was almost literally operating in the dark.

The surgery actually succeeded in its therapeutic goal, but at that time no one was aware that removing these brain structures would almost entirely eliminate his ability to form new memories for facts, events, names, people, or his own personal history after his surgery. As a result he was—as the book’s title implies—adrift in the present moment for the rest of his life. It was as if the narrative thread of his life history were being continuously erased thirty seconds behind the present moment. He had at least some awareness that his memory was not very good, but no grasp of the implications of just how profoundly altered he was, or how limited. An ironic upside to his situation was that with no continuity of personal narrative, he was blithely pleasant and untroubled by the stressors the rest of us experience in life. Scientific study of H.M. produced enormous gains in our understanding of how memory processes operate, including, for instance, the fact that he could improve through practice on motor skills tasks, even though learning for facts or events was almost entirely eliminated.

Corkin gives a sympathetic portrayal of H.M. as an individual, a pleasant, somewhat introverted man with a good sense of humor, who was almost unfailingly cooperative with the scientists who studied him intensively over many years. She also presents a considerable amount of information on learning and memory in an engaging and lucid manner.


This article is part of a historical newspaper archive. Read the original issue for its original layout, photographs and graphics.