Twists and Turns Over Turf Between Psychologists and Counselors

Article archive / May 2017

Originally published: . Volume 8, No. 5. Source pages: 8, 9.

by J. Nelson

Senate Bill 38 appears to be triggering some old turf issues between the counseling and at least some segments of licensed psychology. Over the last decades these turf issues have included diagnosis of the more serious disorders and psychological testing.

One of the most dramatic issues regarding testing resulted in the Louisiana State Board of Examiners filing a lawsuit in 1995 against Boyd J. Atterberry, a licensed professional counselor from Houma. Mr. Atterberry used tests such as the Wechsler, the Bender Gestalt, and the Woodcock-Johnson, saying that his actions fell within the counselors practice act.

Mr. Atterberry argued that the counselor practice act supported his actions. He pointed to the definition of the practice of mental health counseling, sections on “Appraisal,” which include tests of language, educational and achievement tests, adaptive behavioral tests, and symptoms screening checklists or instruments, as well as tests of abilities, interests, and aptitudes, as noted in the act.

The counselor practice act also states “…nothing in this Chapter shall be construed to authorize any person licensed hereunder to administer or interpret tests in accordance with the provisions of R.S. 37:2352(5), except as provided by Title 46, Part LXIII, Chapter 17, Section 1702(E) of the Louisiana Administrative Code, or engage in the practice of psychology.”

The trial judge determined that Atterberry was in violation of the psychology practice act.

Skirmishes continued. In 2008, the Licensed Professional Counselor (LPC) board proposed rules that included assessment and the use of the term “psychological.” This drew strong objections from the psychology board.

But by 2009 the LPC board had adopted a policy to clarify boundaries in a “Position Statement on Appraisal Activities: Clarification of the Distinction between Appraisals and Psychological Tests.” LPCs may not perform intellectual, personality/emotional, or neuropsychological testing. But those qualified by the counselor board can be authorized to use tests of language, education and achievement; adaptive behavioral tests; symptom checklists; and tests of abilities, interests and aptitude.

For many psychologists this truce is working.

However, the Louisiana State Board of Examiners of Psychologists (LSBEP), Chair Darla Burnett, PhD, MP, published an agenda for discussion of SB 38 which included an item, “Review and Discuss SB 38 MORRELL – Relative to potential concerns regarding privileges for Licensed Professional Counselors to perform psychological testing and diagnose severe mental health disorders.” This view seems to have triggered some in the psychology community to view that SB 38 was aimed at psychological testing.

However, SB 38 does in fact have to do with the second turf conflict area, independent diagnosis and treatment of serious mental conditions.

The original practice act of the mental health counselors contains some circular and sometimes vague language. “Mental health counseling services" means those acts and behaviors coming within the practice of mental health counseling as defined in this Chapter,…”

And, “(10) "Practice of mental health counseling" means rendering or offering to individuals, groups, organizations, or the general public by a licensed professional counselor, any service consistent with his professional training …”

Both sides have interpreted the language to support its own view. In the psychology community the objections have often been voiced by Dr. Joe Comaty, who has held positions of authority in state government and also on the psychology board. Comaty, a medical psychologist, has taken a firm stand at times on qualifications of LPCs.

In a 2012 newsletter the Legislative Affairs Chair of the Louisiana Association for Marriage and Family Therapy noted to members, “Dr. Joseph Comaty has been the main psychologist advocating against LPCs and LMFTs in Louisiana.” The author also expressed concerns that the psychology board had allowed this, pointing to ethical requirements for a public board to remain neutral.

So strong were these sentiments that in 2015 Dr. Comaty failed to be confirmed to a second term on the state psychology board. While no group acknowledged blocking his Senate confirmation, it was reported that the counselors were a factor in that action.

In 2010, resolving these conflicts by clarifying the counselors’ scope of practice became the goal of Senator Willie Mount, who put forth a bill to remove some of the vague language in the counselors’ practice act.

Mount offered a bill that would have changed the definition of "mental health counseling" from “assisting an individual or group, through psychotherapy and the counseling relationship, to develop an understanding of personal problems, to define goals, and to plan actions reflecting his or their interests, abilities, aptitudes, and needs as these are related to personal and social concerns, educational progress, and occupations and careers …”

The new language defined mental health counseling, “…includes facilitating human development and wellness throughout the lifespan, and the prevention, assessment, diagnosis, treatment planning and treatment, including psychotherapy, of mental, emotional, behavioral, social and addiction disorders.

The bill never made it to committee. So instead, Senator Mount created the Behavioral Health Professionals Working Group and told psychologists and counselors to resolve their scope of practice differences and develop areas of collaboration. She also directed them to “Identify any additional recommendations which may expand public access to presently absent behavioral health services while avoiding service duplication and redundancy.”

The group failed to meet the goals. Over nine meetings and interim discussions no solutions were reached.

According to the Working Group’s final report, the core of differences revolved around diagnosing mental illness. “The counselors believe that the current statute authorizes counselors to diagnose and treat mental and emotional disorders.” However, the authors wrote, “The psychologists disagree and hold that the current practice act for counselors granted a limited diagnostic scope of practice to counselors that is commensurate with their current master’s degree level of training.”

The psychologists serving where all affiliated with medical psychology and included Dr. Comaty, Dr. Darla Burnett, and Dr. Jessica Brown. They suggested that LPCs place themselves under the psychology board, an idea that was met with dismay by LPCs. Later Comaty wrote to the Senate Committee saying “… LSBEP’s patient efforts to bring its legitimate concerns to the attention of the LPC board have been met with intransigence.” Senator Mount said in a hearing that her goal in establishing the Working Group “…was simply to provide the most optimal starting point possible which would maximize the chances of successful compromise and collaboration.” However the participants of the working group were not successful, “to my dismay,” she said.

The failure of the Working Group prompted the Senator to send a letter to both communities criticizing the lack of a clear resolution and warning them that she would submit a bill to consolidate the boards in order to force cooperation.

“The constant bickering between these two boards is not in the best interest of either profession. Psychologists and LPCs have a real opportunity to develop some innovative practice techniques if the two regulatory boards would spend even half the time collaborating on how to make their professions better as they have spent on senselessly fighting with each other,” Mount wrote.

“With the history of senseless conflict and fighting and the failure of the professions to take advantage of the opportunity provided by the working group, I am left with no other options other than to introduce legislation to consolidate these boards.”

Mount made good on her threat and proposed a bill for consolidating the psychology and LPC board, SB 268. It was strongly opposed by both sides.

During the same time, important testimony from Department of Health and Hospitals Deputy Secretary Kathy Kliebert was included in hearings, regarding LPCs diagnosing.

Senator Cheek asked Ms. Kliebert, “Can an LPC bill Medicaid?” Kliebert said “…individual practitioners are not able to bill for those services.” She continued, “One of the things we’re doing in developing our new Louisiana Behavioral Health Care Partnership is developing a system that would allow the individual practitioners to bill in accordance with their scope of practice.”

Senator Cheek commented about the gap in services in the state and asked if an “all hands on deck” approach was what was needed? To this Kliebert said, “I totally agree. We have problems in terms of getting the provider capacity we need for mental health in Louisiana. We know that. Whatever we can do to get people the right level of services and the right credentialed counselor works for everybody.” “That is one of the things we’re trying to do in our reform of our managed behavioral care that we’re moving to, is to be able to do that,” Kliebert said. “To be able to allow them–the practitioners–to bill in those individual locations, at schools, in home services, where they need those services, vs. us having to provide more expensive clinic- based services or more expensive institutional services.”

Senator Cheek asked, “Can LPCs diagnose across the full spectrum?” Kliebert said, “No, not according to their current scope of practice… That clarification of the scope of practice would certainly help in our future, because we’re quoting what is in scope of practice.”

Mount backed off the effort to consolidate the boards, which some viewed later to be a maneuver to lay the foundation for the counselor bill. Others considered it a sincere effort to increase providers for the Medicaid system.

The measure, SB 268, passed and became Act 320. But along with clarifying the counselors’ scope of practice, behind the scenes negotiations resulted in a collaboration and consultation clause, for psychiatric prescribers under the medical board.

Psychologists were not included in those that could provide consultation and collaboration to LPCs. The Legislative Chair for LPA at the time was Dr. Brown, who handled negotiations. Shortly afterward Brown quit LPA and was listed as a medical psychologist on the state medical board list.

In 2012, the counselors engaged Senator Mills to help soften the language through SB216. The paragraph was amended to include “when medication may be indicated.” The language requiring that the patient be under “active care” of a medical professional was deleted. Also the requirement for consulting was softened with “in accordance with industry best practices, consults and collaborates…”

And advanced practice registered psychiatric nurse practitioners were added, “licensed by the Louisiana State Board of Nursing.”

In 2014 the Marriage & Family Therapists clarified their scope of practice, and the same consultation and collaboration language, for medication, was added.

There have been no known recent turf battles over psychological testing between psychologists and counselors. However, recently a physician asked the medical board if she could sign off on psychological testing and the medical board agreed, if the physician judged herself as qualified.

In 2014 Dr. John Fanning (L) spoke for the Louisiana Psychological Association and Dr. Jacqueline Mims, LPC (R) also testified regarding qualifications. Representative James is center.


This article is part of a historical newspaper archive. Read the original issue for its original layout, photographs and graphics.