Licensee Rights’ Bills Earn Mixed Results

Article archive / June 2019

Originally published: . Volume 10, No. 6. Source pages: 1, 6.

SB 29 by Sen. Patrick Cortez passed the Senate with a 38 to 0 vote and House on May 30 with a vote of 97 to 0. The measure will protect free speech rights in those disciplined by regulatory boards.

However, a measure that would have put additional due process requirements in place was tabled in the Commerce Committee. Senator Cortez's measure will ensure that no professional or occupational licensing board or commission shall:

(1) Enter into a consent decree with a licensee, permittee, or certificate holder if such decree contains a nondisparagement clause. Such a nondisparagement clause contained in a consent decree is contrary to public policy of this state and shall be null, void, and unenforceable, said the measure. Or (2) Initiate any disciplinary actions against a licensee, permittee, or certificate holder for providing testimony or records to a legislative body.

Senator Milkovich's attempt was more comprehensive, and would have prohibited the boards from having a rule, regulation, or any contract that requires the licensee to waive any legal or constitutional rights to have access to the courts, due process, discovery, evidence, or any other right established pursuant to proposed law.

It would have allowed a licensee to have his case transferred to the division of administrative law or an independent administrative law judge. Senator Milkovich said "I don't think it is justice when the judge is paid by the board, the jury is the board, and the prosecutor is paid by the board. That's exactly, that's antithetical and inimical to due process."

The measure contained a number of checks on boards, including that notice of complaints be within 10 days of receipt by the board, including the name of the person making the complaint and identification of the board staff member making the complaint if it originated with the board staff member. It would have required the notice to the licensee to include a detailed description of the complaint. The measure would prohibit the board investigator from having communications with the board or executive director unless the licensee subject to the complaint is present. It would have required that all files of the board regarding the complaint and investigation be available to the licensee through full discovery and that all relevant facts of the case be included in the record. The measure would have restricted the use of anonymous hearsay testimony during a hearing and grant the licensee the right to confront witnesses.

Regulatory boards filed numerous cards with the committee, to express "information." However, based on the testimony given, it appeared that the boards opposed the measure.

In 2018 Milkovich proposed SB 286 called "The Physician's Bill of Rights." That measure passed the Senate but failed in the House Health & Welfare Committee. This year Senator Milkovich tried to extend it to cover all boards, calling it the "Licensee's Bill of Rights." Senator Milkovich testified that licensees' rights of due process are being violated.

"I don't think it is justice when the judge is paid by the board, the jury is the board, and the prosecutor is paid by the board. That's exactly, that's antithetical and inimical to due process."


This article is part of a historical newspaper archive. Read the original issue for its original layout, photographs and graphics.