Article archive / December 2019
Originally published: . Volume 10, No. 12. Source pages: 15.
Rednecks, Redeemers, and Race by Stephen Cresswell
Bill McCown, PhD Professor, Associate Dean College of Business and Social Sciences. ULM
This scholarly work about our eastern neighbor may be an odd choice for contemporary holiday reading. But it may have important lessons for today’s national discourse.
After the Civil War Mississippi, once the jewel of the Confederacy, was in
economic ruins. But the unfathomable nightmare of slavery was finally legally over. From these ashes there was at last a hope for what Walt Whitman saw as a bright and uniquely American Transformation. For a brief while, both freedmen and poor rural whites, most of whom were just simple frontier dwellers, were actually learning to coexist as equals, as Americans. For once they could share in the possibilities of economic progress and justice that this new American experiment now promised. However, this hope was just a brief glimmer. It was soon back to business as usual with the antebellum planting class regaining its berth on top. And just as soon Mississippi was economically foundering, trapped in a spire of poverty. It has never emerged from this mire. What happened?
Cresswell, a historian by training, is gentle in his assignment of blame. But his data suggests that federal and state governments, business interests, and even religious forces kept Mississippi backwards. First they did this by fostering fierce class and social divisions. Then they stifled the Constitutional rights of the newly freed African Americans, codifying racism into practically every aspect of Mississippi life. They followed up by limiting similar rights and opportunities for the majority of poor whites and certainly the remaining native peoples. This was followed with a social agenda that caused generations of poverty by stifling business and economic competitiveness and limiting educational opportunities. But there really was no grand conspiracy. No one was pulling any master strings. In the end there was no single culprit, only many self-serving and even some well-intentioned actors and interests from every political spectrum. There were many people to blame, united only by their lack of vision.
In retrospect the history of Mississippi makes it clear that individual rights and freedom, as the conservative economists now argue, are essential to prosperity. So too is investment in education, as progressives now note. Both the left and the right have something to learn from the history of our neighbors. Both sides could also do a bit better talking with each other and pointing fingers a little less. Our current stakes are very high.
This article is part of a historical newspaper archive. Read the original issue for its original layout, photographs and graphics.