Who Recommends What: Religious Beliefs, Evolutionary Psychiatry, and Mental Health in America

Article archive / December 2019

Originally published: . Volume 10, No. 12. Source pages: 14.

Matt Rossano, PhD Professor, Past Chair, Department of Psychology Southeastern Louisiana University Author Religious Beliefs, Evolutionary Psychiatry and Mental Health in America by Kevin Flannelly

Author Kevin Flannelly says something interesting and a bit surprising on p. 183 of his book: “There is very little evidence that belief in God, in and of itself, is related to mental health….” Given this, one might wonder how you fill the pages of an over 300-page book dedicated to the subject. It turns out that mere belief is relatively unimportant. The content of belief is critical. Flannelly reviews a considerable body of research showing that believing positive things about God, the afterlife, the world and one’s place in it have important beneficial effects on psychiatric symptoms associated with anxiety disorders, agoraphobia, depression, obsessive/compulsive disorder, and paranoia. For example, if one believes that God is loving and benevolent then life satisfaction goes up and psychiatric symptoms go down. However, the opposite is true if one sees God as wrathful and punishing. Since most believers hold the former view, by and large, religion plays a positive role in their mental health. A laudable strength of the book is how it situates the empirical work both historically and neuroscientifically. The human brain evolved to assess threat. Religious belief puts that threat within the larger context of a munificent, meaningful universe.


This article is part of a historical newspaper archive. Read the original issue for its original layout, photographs and graphics.