Political Diversity

Article archive / November 2022

Originally published: . Volume 13, No. 11. Source pages: 2.

Political Diversity by J. Nelson

The country is in quite a tizzy. Even the Stress in America survey is showing that most people are fed up, stressed out, and down on government. Being the one profession that might be able to help resolve conflicts of this type and magnitude, does psychology have a role in this? I think yes. But only if we make a paradigm shift.

In an article, "Faculty Voter Registration in Economics, History, Journalism, Law, and Psychology," in Econ Journal Watch, some economists got together and figured out what we already know–– but it is shocking anyway. The faculty ratio of Democrats to Republicans in psychology is 17.4 to 1. Sadly, journalism is even worse at 20 to 1.

Some years back, a study by Yoel Inbar & Joris Lammers, found that psychology is predominately liberal. Only six percent described themselves as conservative “overall.” The report was picked up by the media which emphasized the juicy news that psychologists discriminate against their conservative colleagues, and those colleagues are hiding in the closet. This lack of diversity of values leads to a homogeneous, groupthink culture and a tendency toward overconfidence in group judgment. Limited political diversity, just like limited ethnic/racial diversity in a group, reeks havoc on quality decision-making. Psychologists are well versed in this dynamic––at least when it comes to everybody else.

But we are just as vulnerable to the unavoidable traps of social judgment: ignoring base-rates, being misled by compelling details, my side bias, selective attention, and so on.

When problems are complex, when the issue in front of our nose clashes with our preexisting beliefs, when time separates our dots, when we are tired, and so on, we are prone to flawed judgment. Nobel Prize winning psychologist Daniel Kahneman would probably tell us that we are influenced by “WYSIATI” – What You See Is All There Is.

The most common human judgment error is probably overconfidence. Even when we are 98 percent sure that we are correct, we are only right 68 percent of the time.

Are we in an age of overconfidence? Stanley Silverman, an IO psychologist, might say so. “Arrogance has run amok lately,” he wrote in, “Arrogance: A Formula for Leadership Failure.” He said that we are in an “age of arrogance" which promotes a “weak learning orientation."

Psychology’s liberal worldview is certainly an honorable one: concern for the well-being and dignity of all people, compassion for those in need, openness, tolerance, appreciation of intellectual pursuits. But at 94 percent, can we prove we aren’t neck deep in groupthink?

Groupthink. The warm, comforting molasses of friends who feel and think exactly the way we do, who support us and never criticize. To know we’ll be always validated, that we and our best friends are on the right side of things. That all is well in Mudville. That our daddy’s rich and our mama’s good looking.

The military suicide rate is a serious concern. Our returning servicemen and servicewomen say we don’t get it. “The public does not understand the problems faced by those in the military or their families,” 84 percent of the veterans say.

Could undiagnosed groupthink account for problems that appear to have no straightforward answer? “The amount of fundamental discovery is staggering, and medical journals are chocked with spectacular science,” writes Julio Licinio, MD, editor of Molecular Psychiatry. “Paradoxically, research advances have not led to new cures,” he writes in an editorial.

Research doesn’t lead to cures? Imagine that.


This article is part of a historical newspaper archive. Read the original issue for its original layout, photographs and graphics.